Moleskine Vs Leuchtturm1917 — Which Notebook Is Better?
=======================================================
Do you know over $10 billion is spent on stationery every year, and Moleskine alone sells more than 17 million notebooks annually? If you’re a writer, student, or creative professional, you’ve likely faced the classic debate: Moleskine vs Leuchtturm1917. The right notebook isn’t just paper; it’s your idea vault, a planner, and sometimes, a trusted daily companion. But which one truly delivers the best value, durability, and writing experience?
This guide breaks down every key factor: paper quality, design, price, and beyond. Whether you’re buying your first premium notebook or upgrading your go-to tool, you’ll find clear answers here. Let’s see how these legendary notebooks compare—and which one is the smarter choice for your needs.
Get 1 Free Audiobook To Keep
Start a 30-day free trial and pick any title from 700,000+ audiobooks. Your first book is yours forever, even if you cancel immediately.
Brand Legacy And Philosophy
Moleskine
Moleskine is inspired by classic notebooks used by artists like Picasso and Hemingway. Founded in 1997, the brand focuses on minimalism and creativity, making their products feel artistic and timeless. Their marketing emphasizes a connection to famous thinkers, aiming to spark your imagination.
Leuchtturm1917
Leuchtturm1917 is a German brand with a history dating back to 1917. Their slogan, “Details make all the difference,” matches their practical, detail-oriented design. The brand is especially loved by bullet journalists and organizers because of its focus on usability and structure.
Non-obvious insight: Many people don’t realize that Leuchtturm1917’s attention to detail (like numbered pages and multiple bookmarks) is rooted in its archival background, where organization and quality were essential.
Design And Aesthetic
Cover And Colors
Moleskine offers a sleek, classic black cover in hard and soft options, plus limited editions. Their look is minimalist.
Leuchtturm1917 stands out with vivid color choices—over 20 shades. Their covers are slightly textured for grip and come in soft or hard finishes.
Pro tip: If you want your notebook to express your personality, Leuchtturm1917’s color range gives you more freedom.
Size Options
Both brands offer a variety of sizes, but with some differences:
| Size | Moleskine | Leuchtturm1917 |
|---|---|---|
| 3.5″ x 5.5″ | 3.5″ x 6″ | |
| Medium (A5) | 5″ x 8.25″ | 5.75″ x 8.25″ |
| Large | 7.5″ x 10″ | 7.5″ x 10″ |
Takeaway: Leuchtturm1917’s A5 is a bit wider, giving more writing space.
Paper Quality And Writing Experience
Thickness And Bleed-through
Moleskine paper is 70 gsm (grams per square meter) in most notebooks. Leuchtturm1917 uses 80 gsm paper, which is thicker.
People who use fountain pens or heavy inks notice more bleed-through and ghosting on Moleskine pages. Leuchtturm1917 performs better for most pens, with less ink showing through.
Texture And Feel
Moleskine’s paper is smooth but can feel thin. Leuchtturm1917 offers a slightly toothier texture, which some artists and pen users prefer.
Beginner mistake: Many first-time buyers assume Moleskine’s famous brand means better paper, but for fountain pen users or sketchers, Leuchtturm1917 is often the superior choice.
Ruling Styles
Both brands provide dotted, lined, plain, and squared options. Leuchtturm1917 is especially popular for dot grid notebooks, a favorite among bullet journalists.
Non-obvious insight: If you love bullet journaling or diagramming, Leuchtturm1917’s dots are lighter and less intrusive than Moleskine’s, helping your layouts look cleaner.
Features And Usability
Page Numbering And Index
Leuchtturm1917 includes numbered pages and a built-in index in almost every notebook. This makes finding notes or tracking projects much easier.
Moleskine does not number its pages or provide a pre-made index. You’ll need to create your own system.
Real-world use: If you’re managing tasks, research, or project notes, Leuchtturm1917’s organization system saves time.
Bookmarks And Extras
Moleskine provides one ribbon bookmark. Leuchtturm1917 gives you two, letting you mark multiple sections at once.
Both brands include:
- Expandable back pockets
- Elastic closure bands
Leuchtturm1917 also adds:
- Sticker labels for archiving
- Perforated pages at the back for easy removal
Stat box
Did you know? 87% of bullet journal fans on Reddit recommend Leuchtturm1917 for its organizational features.
Credit: www.youtube.com
Durability And Build
Binding
Both use thread-bound spines, allowing the notebook to lay flat. This is essential for comfortable writing.
Moleskine’s binding is reliable but sometimes prone to splitting if the notebook is overstuffed. Leuchtturm1917’s binding is reinforced and slightly more resistant to heavy use.
Cover Strength
Hardcover versions from both brands are sturdy, but Leuchtturm1917’s covers are a bit thicker. For bags and travel, Leuchtturm1917’s build gives better protection.
Pro tip: If you’re rough on your notebooks or carry them everywhere, Leuchtturm1917 may last longer.
Price And Value
Retail Cost
- Moleskine Classic Large (A5): ~$22 USD
- Leuchtturm1917 Medium (A5): ~$25 USD
Sales, edition differences, or local prices can shift costs by a few dollars.
Value For Money
Moleskine is often slightly cheaper, especially in smaller sizes or on sale. However, Leuchtturm1917’s extra features (numbered pages, two bookmarks, thicker paper) often justify the higher price for many users.
Callout: Is it worth it?
Tip: If you buy only one or two notebooks a year, spending a little more for better organization and paper can save you frustration in the long run.
Credit: www.reddit.com
Environmental And Ethical Factors
Moleskine manufactures mainly in China, while Leuchtturm1917 produces in Europe.
- Leuchtturm1917: FSC-certified paper, more transparent about environmental policies.
- Moleskine: States commitment to sustainability but provides less detail.
If eco-friendliness matters, Leuchtturm1917 is the more transparent choice.
Pros And Cons At A Glance
Here’s a quick comparison to help you see the strengths and weaknesses of each brand:
| Feature | Moleskine | Leuchtturm1917 |
|---|---|---|
| Paper Quality | Good, thin, some bleed | Excellent, thick, little bleed |
| Page Numbering | No | Yes |
| Color Options | Limited | Wide range |
| Bookmarks | One | Two |
| Price | Cheaper | Higher |
| Archival Features | No | Labels, index |
Who Should Choose Each Notebook?
Moleskine Is Best For:
- Fans of classic, minimalist design
- Those who want a lightweight notebook
- People using ballpoint or gel pens (not heavy inks)
- Budget-conscious users
Leuchtturm1917 Is Best For:
- Bullet journalists and organizers
- Fountain pen users and sketchers
- Anyone needing more structure (index, numbered pages)
- People who want durability and color choice
Key Decision Factors
- Paper Quality: Leuchtturm1917 wins for thick, pen-friendly paper.
- Organization: Leuchtturm1917’s index and numbering help track information.
- Design: Moleskine offers classic elegance; Leuchtturm1917 brings fun color.
- Durability: Both are strong, but Leuchtturm1917 edges ahead.
- Price: Moleskine is more affordable but with fewer features.
Beginner tip: If you’re unsure, try both brands in a small size first. Many art supply stores offer sample pages or open notebooks to test with your pens before buying.
Credit: www.urbancottageindustries.com
Common Myths Vs Facts
| Myth | Fact |
|---|---|
| Moleskine has the best paper for all pens | Leuchtturm1917’s is thicker and handles ink better |
| Leuchtturm1917 is only for bullet journals | It’s great for notes, sketches, and planning too |
| Moleskine is always cheaper | Not always; prices vary by edition and store |
| All Moleskines are made in Italy | Most are produced in China; Leuchtturm1917 is made in Europe |
Final Verdict
If you want the best paper quality, organization, and durability, Leuchtturm1917 is the clear winner. It costs a bit more, but for most users—especially students, creatives, and professionals—the extra features and longevity are worth it.
Moleskine remains a strong choice if you love classic style, want something lightweight, or need to save a few dollars.
Actionable takeaway: Match your notebook to your main use. For bullet journaling, project management, or fountain pens, pick Leuchtturm1917. For daily notes and simple lists with basic pens, Moleskine is still a solid option.
For more info on the history and features of both brands, check out Wikipedia’s Moleskine page.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Leuchtturm1917 Better For Fountain Pens?
Yes, the 80 gsm paper in Leuchtturm1917 notebooks handles fountain pen ink much better than Moleskine’s thinner paper. There’s less bleed-through and ghosting.
Does Moleskine Offer More Cover Designs?
Moleskine releases many limited edition covers (like Harry Potter, Star Wars), but Leuchtturm1917 consistently offers more color choices in their main lineup.
Which Notebook Lasts Longer With Daily Use?
Leuchtturm1917 generally lasts longer due to thicker covers and more robust binding. If you use your notebook heavily, it’s the better investment.
Can You Use Watercolors In Either Notebook?
Neither brand is made for watercolors, but Leuchtturm1917’s thicker paper will handle light washes better. For heavy painting, consider a dedicated watercolor sketchbook.
Are The Notebooks Refillable?
No, both Moleskine and Leuchtturm1917 are bound notebooks. Once full, you need to buy a new one. If you want a refillable system, look for ring binders or disc-bound notebooks.
Key Takeaway Box
Summary: For most professionals and students, Leuchtturm1917’s features, paper quality, and durability make it the best choice. Moleskine offers style and tradition at a lower price. Test both if you can—your writing tools should fit your needs, not just your brand loyalty.
